Court affirms contractual exclusion of the prevention principle

Nov 16, 2026

In Tallai Project Group Pty Ltd v Ellair Solutions Pty Ltd [2026] NSWSC 1332, the Supreme Court of New South Wales considered (among other things) whether parties to an HVAC subcontract had contractually excluded the prevention principle by way of a unilateral extension of time (EOT) clause which operated for the contractor’s benefit.

Tallai engaged Ellair as a mechanical services subcontractor on the Southwest Sydney Metro project.  The works experienced significant delays, including in relation to site access issues arising from COVID-19 restrictions.

The subcontract contained a detailed EOT regime that permitted Ellair to claim an EOT where completion was likely to be delayed by matters beyond its reasonable control, subject to complying with prescribed notice requirements.  The EOT regime also gave Tallai unilateral power to extend time even if Ellair had not made a claim.  Specifically, clause 27.4(a) of the subcontract entitled Tallai to exercise that power “in its sole and absolute discretion for the benefit of the Contractor”, at any time, for any reason it considered appropriate. Ellair did not make any EOT claims during the project.

Disputes arose, and Tallai sought to recover amounts from Ellair in relation to, among other things, liquidated damages. Ellair submitted that a principal with a unilateral power to extend the time for completion is obliged to exercise that power honestly and fairly, having regard to the underlying rationale of the prevention principle, or alternatively, that there is an implied duty to exercise the power in good faith. Ellair asserted that given the potential liability to pay liquidated damages, the Court should strive to avoid an interpretation that would punish the subcontractor, not for delaying the works, but for failing to submit paperwork within a required timeframe. Tallai submitted that clause 27.4(a) of the subcontract excluded the prevention principle meaning that Tallai was not obliged to extend the time for completion.

Ultimately, Rees J agreed with Tallai, finding that the parties had contractually excluded the prevention principle.

In reaching this decision, her Honour distinguished earlier authorities including Peninsula Balmain Pty Ltd v Abigroup Contractors Pty Ltd [2002] NSWCA 211 and Clarke Energy (Australia) Pty Ltd v Alinta Energy Transmission (Roy Hill) Pty Ltd [2026] NSWSC 1124, in which a principal’s unilateral power to extend time was found to attract an obligation to act honestly and fairly having regard to the prevention principle.

In this case, Rees J placed particular emphasis on the express words that Tallai could exercise its unilateral power “in its sole and absolute discretion for the benefit of the Contractor” (emphasis added).  Her Honour considered that the obligation to exercise the unilateral power to extend the time for completion for Ellair’s benefit in response to Tallai’s own acts of prevention was inconsistent with the express terms of the unilateral power in the subcontract.  It therefore followed that:

  • Tallai was not obliged to exercise its unilateral power to grant Ellair an EOT where Ellair had failed to claim an EOT, notwithstanding Tallai’s own acts of prevention; and
  • as the prevention principle was excluded, Ellair was liable to pay Tallai liquidated damages.

This case provides an important illustration of the distinction between a unilateral EOT power, which may attract an obligation to exercise it honestly and fairly to avoid the prevention principle, and an EOT power drafted expressly as exercisable in the principal’s sole discretion for its own benefit.

The decision can be viewed here.

Share

Related Insights

See all insights
Nov 5, 2026

Monthly Project Insights – October Edition

Read more
Oct 29, 2026

Calling on Security: Queensland Court of Appeal Clarifies Contractual Recourse Rights

Read more
Oct 29, 2026

Federal and State Governments publish guidelines for data centre developments

Read more